Friday, 19 March 2010 07:57
Written by Village of Lions Bay EPOST
Sent on behalf of Lions Bay Council:
While we welcome all remarks from residents on initiatives of Council, we do need to correct any errors of fact. Several are needed as regards an e-mail circulated by a resident within the last several days, within the Village.
The subject is Council’s current Age-Friendly Housing initiative. For those not familiar with it, we will give the background to the initiative, first, Then we will address the errors of fact in the e-mail.
IMPORTANT: The resident has also circulated draft surveys on this initiative. Please do not complete any 'draft' survey on Age Friendly Housing that has not been sent to you directly from the Village of Lions Bay. You will not be working with a correct, finalized survey instrument and we will not be able to use your response. Thank you for your attention.
1. Background of the Age Friendly Housing Initiative
· A process is underway; a survey is being designed. Council has engaged a consultant to design a survey to elicit Villagers’ interests, opinions and needs regarding age-friendly housing. To date, one workshop has been held to feed back on the draft survey. One more is scheduled, intended for those who attended the first. It will be for the purpose of getting further advice on the scope and nature of the questions for the survey – not for collecting the opinions of this group, or any other, as that is what the survey will do. A survey of residents will then be conducted. The work is being funded through a grant we received last year under the Age Friendly Communities initiative ,sponsored through the Federation of Canadian Municipalities.
· We need to look into Age Friendly Housing. Council undertook
this initiative when we saw that grant funding was available for work
on Age Friendly Communities. This is an area where Council needs to
explore and understand Villagers’ opinions and needs. With over a
third of our population over age 55 in the last Census, we are among
many communities in the world with a high population of elderly
residents – in the last Census, over one-third of us were aged 55 and
over. Council’s talks with Lions Bay seniors have revealed that
housing is a main concern. Many might like to downsize, but Lions Bay
lacks options for those who might like to do so. We are a community of
large, single family residences.
· We are looking for views; not to support a development. All
Village residents would receive the surveys on Age Friendly housing.
In this initiative, Council is working from the ground up. We have no
specific ideas around appropriate kinds of age-friendly development for
the Village - not at this point. Our intent is to run as neutral a
process as possible to draw views from the community at large as to
what the needs and interests are in age friendly housing. The
consultant is under our instructions to that effect.
· There will be opportunity for feedback and more input. The
results of the surveys would be discussed at a public meeting to be
scheduled in May. The data and residents’ views from the meeting could
feed into decisions around building codes, programs to help older
people stay in their houses as long as possible, etc. They might
conceivably also point to having Council explore age-friendly
developments. Our OCP does say that Council should "explore"
multi-family developments. However, there would be much more work to
do, and a comprehensive process of community input and
consensus-building, to arrive at any go-forward on development of
age-friendly transitional housing.
2. Errors of Fact Needing Correction
The recent e-mail was from a resident who participated in the first
workshop and circulated a first draft survey form. Errors of fact that
Council would like to address are the following remarks:
· “… the sole purpose of the group of attendees was to bring
about a condo/townhouse development for "seniors", without
consideration of any other solutions around ageing or alternative ways
to assist seniors to stay in the village.”
Correction: In getting participants for the workshops, the Village of
Lions Bay asked for people to attend two workshops, scheduled one week
apart, to look over the draft survey of attitudes and needs, with
respect to age-friendly housing. We invited residents to sign up if
they fell into one of three different categories – a) people soon to
need transitional housing, b) those who might need it within five
years, and c) members of the general public with an interest in
age-friendly housing. Certainly, some workshop participants would
like to see some development of transitional housing in Lions Bay.
However, the workshops are only intended to develop a questionnaire
that is fair and objective, to explore the needs and opinions of all
Villagers, which may vary widely. It is those views from the wider
community which will help shape anything that Council might undertake
as follow-up – not the opinions of the group who fed into survey
design.
· “The workshop is being run by a small, special interest group
including a developer who has been spearheading this initiative for
some years.”
Correction: The workshops are being run by Raymond Penner, a
professional consultant with over 30 years experience in community
processes. He is being paid by the Village of Lions Bay, under the Age
Friendly grant we received. No developer is spearheading this
initiative; it is being conducted by Council. To our knowledge, one
developer did participate in the workshop.
· Those attending had obviously had extensive discussion around
such a development, because they already know it a) will be a
"Whistler-style" multi-unit structure b) would not cater for seniors in
need of care or with mobility issues c) would not be available to other
age groups and d) should only be available to those who have lived in
the village for many years.
Correction: Since Council is neither envisioning nor fostering any
particular development, the workshop group could not “know” anything
around a development. These notions did surface at the workshop
itself, as background issues or ideas of what to ask residents in
surveying their opinions and interests regarding Age-Friendly housing.
· “I asked how council could ensure that at least a a quorum of
responses was obtained, and Brenda's response was that flyers in the
mailbox and e-mails from the village were sent out, which means council
has done what is required, and that a questionaire in mailboxes is
sufficient communication to gauge public opinion on the hot topic of
condos/townhouses in Lions Bay.”
Correction: The Mayor advised the gallery at the March 15th meeting
that two e-posts and two mail outs had gone out to the community to
invite participation in the survey design workshops, and further we
phoned to invite people as a result of receiving a low response to the
Village invitation for volunteers to participate. The Village of Lions
Bay Council discussed later in the meeting how we could create further
communication with the community on the upcoming survey, and on other
Council initiatives.
· The questionnaire does not allow for an unequivocal "no condos/townhouses" response.
Correction: The resident chose to circulate the first draft of the
surveys on Tuesday March 16th, in advance of seeing the second draft of
the survey at the second workshop on Saturday March 20th. The
consultant advises Council that the second draft would address this
point.
Again, we would also request – importantly - that no-one fill out any
survey they receive by e-mail. It is regrettable that copies of draft
surveys are now circulating, as this may be confusing to people. The
Village will be sending all residents a finalized survey, when the
design is complete, together with instructions on returning it.
Thank you.
Trackback(0)